Part of the Live Finger Lakes networkExplore the region ›

Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarms in Keuka Lake Homes: NY Rules and Winter Safety

Last reviewed: November 11, 2026. General information only, not legal or fire-protection engineering advice. The legal requirements below come from New York Executive Law section 378 and the state’s Uniform Fire Prevention and Building Code as summarized by state agencies; your local code enforcement officer has the final word on your building.

As an Amazon Associate, Living on Keuka earns from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure.

Late fall is when Keuka Lake houses close up. Storm windows go in, the furnace or boiler runs around the clock, wood stoves get lit for the first time since April, and on the first stormy night of the season somebody drags the portable generator out of the shed. All of that is normal lake-country life, and all of it is a reason to look up at the ceiling and ask a simple question: do the smoke and carbon monoxide alarms in this house actually work?

This guide covers what New York law requires in a one- or two-family home, what fire-safety groups recommend on top of the legal minimum, where the alarms should go in the kinds of houses we have around the lake (old farmhouses, converted cottages, walkout basements and attached garages), the seller’s affidavit you’ll sign or receive at closing, rentals, and what to do the night an alarm goes off. It’s part of our Year-Round Living section and pairs with our guides to wood stoves and chimneys, generators and power outages and heating systems.

Why this matters more in a lake-country winter

Most homes around Keuka burn something for heat: heating oil, propane, natural gas in the villages, wood or pellets. Every one of those fuels can produce carbon monoxide when it burns incompletely, and the National Fire Protection Association’s carbon monoxide safety page adds vehicles and generators running in an attached garage to the list. The CDC’s CO poisoning basics put the national toll at more than 400 deaths a year from unintentional CO poisoning not linked to fires, more than 100,000 emergency department visits and more than 14,000 hospitalizations. CO is odorless and colorless, and the CDC warns that people who are asleep can die before they ever notice symptoms.

Fire risk climbs at the same time. NFPA’s heating safety research estimates that fire departments responded to an average of 37,365 home fires involving heating equipment per year from 2020 to 2024, with about 417 civilian deaths a year, and that nearly half of those heating fires (46 percent) happened from December through February. Space heaters and heating stoves accounted for 30 percent of heating fires but 73 percent of the deaths.

Add the realities of rural living: long fire-department response times on the hills above the lake, older houses with balloon framing and no fire blocking, bedrooms tucked under knee walls, and seasonal homes that sat empty for months while batteries died. NFPA’s smoke alarm guidance notes you may have as little as two minutes to get out once a fire starts, and that working smoke alarms cut the risk of dying in a home fire by about 60 percent.

What New York law requires in a one- or two-family home

Two subdivisions of Executive Law section 378, the statute behind the state Uniform Code, set the baseline for houses.

Smoke alarms

  • Every one- or two-family dwelling, and every condo or co-op unit used as a residence, must have an operable single-station smoke alarm or alarms (Executive Law 378(5-b)).
  • The alarms must be placed so they are clearly audible in each bedroom or other room used for sleeping, with the doors closed.
  • Battery-operated alarms are allowed for this requirement in existing homes.

Since April 1, 2019, a separate state law has limited which alarms can be sold. As the Department of State’s announcement explains, every new or replacement smoke alarm offered for sale in New York must be either hard-wired to the building or powered by a sealed, non-removable battery with at least a 10-year life. The law didn’t force anyone to tear out existing compliant alarms, but when you replace one or add one, the new alarm has to meet that standard. The Assembly’s consumer brochure on the smoke detector law adds that homeowners and landlords should upgrade before selling or renting, and that local laws can be stricter than the state’s.

Carbon monoxide alarms (Amanda’s Law)

Amanda’s Law took effect February 22, 2010. It is named for Amanda Hansen, a Buffalo teenager who died of CO poisoning from a defective boiler while sleeping over at a friend’s house in 2009, according to the state Division of Homeland Security and Emergency Services’ carbon monoxide toolbox. Under Executive Law 378(5-a), every one- or two-family dwelling, condo or co-op unit and multiple dwelling must have an operable CO alarm, but only where the home has an appliance, device or system that can emit CO, or has an attached garage. In practice that covers almost every lake house: an oil or propane furnace, a gas water heater, a wood stove, a fireplace or an attached garage all trigger it.

The Department of State’s 2010 rule implementing Amanda’s Law spells out placement by age of the house:

Your houseMinimum CO alarm requirementPower
Built before January 1, 2008At least one CO alarm on the lowest story that has a sleeping areaBattery, plug-in or cord-type alarms allowed; no interconnection required
Built on or after January 1, 2008A CO alarm on each story with a sleeping area or a CO sourceHard-wired to building power with battery backup, and interconnected where more than one is required

CO alarms must be listed to UL 2034 or CSA 6.19, installed per the manufacturer’s instructions, kept working, and replaced when they stop working as intended, according to DHSES. Combination smoke/CO alarms are commonly used, as long as the unit is listed for both functions. The state’s fire code also says CO alarms should not be installed in or near garages, bathrooms or furnace rooms, or anywhere the manufacturer’s instructions say not to put them, and that alarms may not be disabled except for service.

Keep in mind that the state minimum is one CO alarm in many older homes. That’s the floor, not the recommendation; see below.

What safety groups recommend beyond the minimum

NFPA’s smoke alarm guidance and CO guidance go further than the law, and their advice is the better target for a house you live in:

  • Smoke alarms inside every bedroom, outside each sleeping area (a hallway), and on every level, including the basement.
  • CO alarms in a central location outside each sleeping area and on every level, plus anywhere else your code requires.
  • Interconnect them so that when one sounds, they all sound. In a big farmhouse or a walkout with bedrooms on two floors, an alarm in the basement won’t wake anyone upstairs unless it’s linked.
  • Mount smoke alarms on the ceiling or high on a wall, and keep them at least 10 feet from the stove to cut nuisance alarms.
  • Test every alarm monthly with the test button.
  • Replace smoke alarms 10 years after the manufacture date printed on the back, and replace CO alarms according to the manufacturer (the CDC suggests every five years if you don’t have other guidance).

If wiring new interconnected alarms isn’t practical in a plaster-walled farmhouse, wireless interconnected 10-year sealed-battery smoke alarms talk to each other by radio and still satisfy New York’s sealed-battery sales rule. For CO, a battery CO alarm with a digital display shows peak readings, which the CDC specifically suggests considering. Hard-wired alarms should be installed by a qualified electrician; our old wiring guide covers what to expect when an electrician opens up an older house.

Which type of smoke alarm?

NFPA explains that ionization alarms respond faster to flaming fires and photoelectric alarms respond faster to smoldering fires. Photoelectric units are the better choice near kitchens and bathrooms because they cause fewer nuisance alarms, and newer multi-criteria alarms labeled “helps reduce cooking nuisance alarms” are worth considering when it’s time to replace. For the best coverage NFPA recommends combination or both types, interconnected. If someone in the house is deaf or hard of hearing, there are strobe alarms and bed or pillow shakers that work with standard alarms.

Where alarms go in a typical Keuka Lake house

Lake homes don’t always look like the floor plans in the brochures. Some common layouts and what to think about:

  • Walkout basement with a guest room. If anyone sleeps down there, that level is your lowest story with a sleeping area, which is where New York requires the CO alarm in a pre-2008 house. It also needs a smoke alarm audible in that bedroom with the door closed. The furnace or boiler is often in the same basement, so keep the CO alarm out of the furnace room itself and outside the bedroom door instead.
  • Old farmhouse with a back staircase and bedrooms in the eaves. Put alarms inside each bedroom and at the top of each stairway. Interconnection matters most here, because a fire on the first floor can fill one staircase without reaching the other.
  • Converted seasonal cottage. Many cottages started with a single alarm by the door. If a cottage now has a heating appliance or a wood stove it didn’t have before, Amanda’s Law applies. Our guide to converting a seasonal cottage covers the code issues that come with year-round use.
  • Attached garage. An attached garage triggers the CO requirement even in an all-electric house. Don’t mount the CO alarm in the garage or right at the garage door, but do put one in the room just inside. Never warm up a car or run a snowblower or generator inside the garage, even with the door open; NFPA and the CDC both warn against it.
  • Wood stove or fireplace room. Keep the smoke alarm far enough away that normal reloading doesn’t set it off, but don’t skip it. Our wood stove guide explains chimney inspections and the permit New York requires before you install a solid-fuel appliance.
  • Second-floor master over a living room with cathedral ceilings. Smoke rises to the peak first. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for peaked ceilings, which usually call for mounting slightly below the peak rather than right at it.

Generators, storms and snow-blocked vents

Winter storms are when CO alarms earn their keep. The CDC’s advice on portable generators is blunt: never run one inside the house or garage, even with doors and windows open, and only run it outside more than 20 feet from windows, doors and vents. Keep a battery-powered or battery-backup CO alarm working whenever you use a generator, because a plug-in alarm without a battery goes dark the moment the power does.

Snow causes its own problems. NFPA reminds homeowners to clear snow away from dryer, furnace, stove and fireplace vents during and after a storm, and to make sure a running car’s exhaust pipe isn’t buried in a snowbank. Many high-efficiency furnaces, boilers and water heaters vent sideways through the wall just above the ground, where drifting snow and plow piles collect. Our guides to generators and outages and ice dams and frozen pipes cover the rest of storm prep. The CDC also recommends having your heating system, water heater and other fuel-burning appliances serviced by a qualified technician every year and having your chimney checked or cleaned annually.

Buying or selling: the smoke and CO affidavit at closing

New York builds alarms into the sale of a house. Executive Law 378(5-b) says that when a one- or two-family dwelling or condo unit is conveyed, the seller must deliver an affidavit to the buyer at closing stating that the home complies with the smoke alarm requirement. The buyer then has 10 days after the conveyance to tell the seller if the alarms don’t work, and the seller bears the cost of fixing it. The statute also says a failure to comply isn’t a breach of warranty in the deed and can’t be used as a defense to a fire insurance claim. In practice, many New York closings use a combined smoke and carbon monoxide affidavit covering both subdivisions.

For sellers, that means testing every alarm, replacing anything past its date with a compliant 10-year sealed or hard-wired unit, and making sure a CO alarm is on the lowest sleeping level before closing day. For buyers, test everything during the final walk-through, check manufacture dates on the backs of the alarms, and calendar that 10-day window. A home inspector will often note missing or expired alarms; see our home inspection guide and closing costs guide for the rest of the closing checklist.

Renting out a lake house

If you rent your place, the alarms are your responsibility as the owner, and the state brochure notes that local laws may be stricter than the state’s. Some towns and counties around the lake now register short-term rentals and may inspect for life-safety items; our short-term rentals guide explains the registration rules in Yates and Steuben counties. Guests don’t know your house, so interconnected alarms, a posted note about what the CO alarm sounds like, a fire extinguisher in the kitchen, and a written escape plan by the door are cheap ways to protect them and you. Ask your insurer what it expects; our home insurance guide lists questions worth raising.

Seasonal homes: the empty-house problem

An alarm in an empty house protects no one, but it still matters when you come back. Before you close up for winter, note the dates on every alarm. When you open the house in spring, or on a winter weekend visit, test every alarm before the first night’s sleep and before the first fire in the stove. If you leave the heat on at a low setting while away, a monitored alarm or a smart alarm that alerts your phone can warn you of a fire or a CO problem in a house no one is watching. Our winterizing guide covers the rest of the close-up checklist.

When an alarm goes off

Smoke alarm

NFPA’s guidance on alarm sounds: three loud beeps in a row, repeated, means smoke or fire. Get out, call 911 from outside, and stay out. A single chirp every 30 or 60 seconds means a low battery. In a sealed 10-year unit, or if the chirping continues after a battery change, the alarm has reached the end of its life and must be replaced.

CO alarm

  • If the CO alarm sounds, NFPA says to move immediately to fresh air outdoors or at an open window or door, make sure everyone is accounted for, and call for help from the fresh-air location. Stay there until emergency responders arrive.
  • Don’t go back in to look for the source or to “air it out” first.
  • If anyone has headache, dizziness, weakness, nausea, vomiting, chest pain or confusion (the CDC calls these “flu-like”), call 911 and say you suspect carbon monoxide.
  • If the alarm gives a different trouble signal rather than the alarm pattern, NFPA says to check the battery; if it keeps sounding after you replace it, call the fire department.
  • Ahead of time, call your local fire department’s non-emergency number and ask which number they want you to call for a CO alarm, as NFPA recommends. Around Keuka the answer in an emergency is 911.

After any real CO event, have the fuel-burning appliances checked by a qualified technician before using them again. A blocked chimney, cracked heat exchanger or snow-covered vent is a common cause.

Free smoke alarms from the Red Cross

The American Red Cross of Western New York runs a Home Fire Campaign that installs free smoke alarms in homes that don’t have them and helps families build an escape plan. Through its Sound the Alarm program you can sign up for a home fire safety visit; availability depends on your location and volunteers. The program is aimed at households that can’t afford alarms or can’t physically install them, so it’s worth passing along to an older neighbor who lives alone on a back road.

A 20-minute November alarm checklist

  • Press the test button on every smoke and CO alarm in the house.
  • Read the manufacture date on the back of each one. Replace smoke alarms older than 10 years and CO alarms past the manufacturer’s replacement date.
  • Confirm there’s a smoke alarm audible in every bedroom with the door closed, and on every level.
  • Confirm there’s a CO alarm on the lowest floor with a bedroom, and ideally on every level with bedrooms or fuel-burning equipment.
  • Make sure at least one CO alarm runs on batteries or has battery backup for power outages.
  • Vacuum dust and cobwebs off the alarms; DHSES recommends cleaning them at least once a year.
  • Book the annual furnace or boiler service and chimney sweep if you haven’t.
  • Walk outside and find every exhaust vent so you know what to clear after a storm.
  • Practice a two-way-out escape plan with everyone who lives in or visits the house, and pick a meeting spot outside.

More for year-round living: our heating costs guide, propane tank guide, heating oil tank guide and older homes guide.

Frequently asked questions

How many smoke alarms does New York require in a house?

State law requires operable smoke alarms placed so they are clearly audible in every bedroom or room used for sleeping with the doors closed. Fire-safety groups such as NFPA recommend more: one inside each bedroom, one outside each sleeping area, and one on every level, ideally interconnected.

Do I need a carbon monoxide detector in New York?

Yes, if your home has any fuel-burning appliance, device or system or an attached garage. Under Amanda’s Law, a home built before 2008 needs at least one CO alarm on the lowest story with a sleeping area; a home built in 2008 or later needs one on each story with a sleeping area or a CO source, hard-wired and interconnected.

Can I still buy smoke alarms with replaceable batteries in New York?

No. Since April 1, 2019, new or replacement smoke alarms sold in New York must be hard-wired or powered by a sealed, non-removable battery that lasts at least 10 years. Existing compliant alarms didn’t have to be removed, but replacements must meet the rule.

Does a seller have to certify smoke alarms at closing?

Yes. Executive Law 378 requires the seller of a one- or two-family home or condo to deliver an affidavit at closing stating the home complies with the smoke alarm requirement. The buyer has 10 days after closing to report alarms that don’t work, and the seller pays to fix them. Combined smoke and CO affidavits are common.

How often should smoke and CO alarms be replaced?

NFPA says smoke alarms should be replaced 10 years after the manufacture date. Replace CO alarms according to the manufacturer’s instructions; the CDC suggests about every five years if you have nothing else to go on.

What should I do if my CO alarm goes off?

Get everyone to fresh air outdoors or at an open window or door right away, call 911 from there, and don’t go back inside until responders say it’s safe. Have fuel-burning appliances checked before using them again.

Can I get free smoke alarms near Keuka Lake?

The American Red Cross of Western New York installs free smoke alarms through its Home Fire Campaign and Sound the Alarm program for households that need them, depending on location and volunteer availability.

Official sources

A Live Finger Lakes network site