Last reviewed: October 27, 2026. General information only, not legal, tax, or lending advice. Tax rates and county fees below come from the NYS Department of Taxation and Finance and the Yates and Steuben County Clerks as posted in October 2026; your lender’s Loan Estimate and your attorney’s closing statement are what count for your purchase.
Buyers shopping around Keuka Lake usually have a number in mind for the house and a rough idea of the down payment. The money that catches people off guard is everything else: mortgage tax, recording fees, title work, the attorney, the inspections, and the property tax and escrow adjustments that show up on the closing statement. In New York those costs follow state law and local custom, and Keuka Lake sits in two counties with different mortgage tax rates, so the same loan costs a little more on one side of the county line than the other.
This guide walks through what a buyer typically pays at a Keuka Lake closing, what the seller typically pays, how the two county clerks’ fees and taxes compare, and how to read your Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure without surprises. It belongs to our Buying and Property Types section and pairs with our guide to buying a home near Keuka Lake and the home inspection guide. We don’t quote attorney, inspector, or lender fees because they vary by firm and by deal; ask for written estimates.
Still choosing a property? Start with our Keuka Lake homes for sale buyer’s guide, then come back here to budget the closing.
Which county is the house in?
Start here, because it decides the mortgage tax rate and which county clerk records your deed and mortgage. The north and west parts of the lake (the towns of Jerusalem, Milo and Barrington, and the Village of Penn Yan) are in Yates County. The south end and much of the east side (the towns of Pulteney, Urbana and Wayne, and the Village of Hammondsport) are in Steuben County. A tax bill or the listing’s tax map number will tell you; our towns and villages guide explains how location changes daily life.
The New York taxes on a home purchase
Real estate transfer tax (usually the seller’s)
New York’s real estate transfer tax is two dollars for each $500 of consideration, which works out to $4 per $1,000 of the price. The Tax Department says the base tax is paid by the seller and may not be shifted to the buyer except by contract, but if the seller doesn’t pay, the buyer becomes liable. On a $400,000 sale the base transfer tax is $1,600.
Buyers of more expensive lakefront homes should know about the additional tax, often called the mansion tax: 1% of the price on residences selling for $1 million or more, paid by the buyer. On a $1.2 million lakefront house that is $12,000, and it applies to the whole price, not just the part over $1 million. The return that reports these taxes, Form TP-584, is filed with the county clerk when the deed is recorded.
Mortgage recording tax (the buyer’s, if you borrow)
If you finance the purchase, New York taxes the privilege of recording the mortgage. According to the Tax Department’s mortgage recording tax page and its Form MT-15 rate tables, the pieces are a basic tax of 50 cents per $100 of mortgage debt, a special additional tax of 25 cents, an additional tax of 25 cents in counties where it hasn’t been suspended, and in some counties a local tax. For a one- or two-family home, the first $10,000 of the loan is deducted when computing the additional tax. Here is how that plays out around the lake:
| Yates County | Steuben County | |
|---|---|---|
| Basic tax (per $100) | $0.50 | $0.50 |
| Special additional tax | $0.25 | $0.25 |
| Additional tax | Not imposed | $0.25 (first $10,000 deducted for 1-2 family homes) |
| County local tax | $0.25 | $0.25 |
| Total per $100 | $1.00 | $1.25 |
| Example: $300,000 mortgage | About $3,000 | About $3,725 |
Sources: NYS Tax Form MT-15 (rev. 1/25) rate tables; Yates County Clerk fee schedule; Steuben County Clerk schedule of fees. The examples are our arithmetic and ignore rounding. Yates County’s local quarter-percent was renewed in December 2025 for two years, through December 1, 2027, so check whether it has been extended if you close after that.
Who actually writes the check for each piece depends on the loan. On many residential mortgages the lender pays the special additional tax, which is one reason the mortgage tax line on your Loan Estimate may be lower than the full rate. Ask your lender or attorney to show you the split. Cash buyers pay no mortgage tax.
County clerk recording fees
Every deed and mortgage is recorded with the county clerk, and each carries a per-document fee plus a per-page charge. Two state forms are filed with the deed: the TP-584 transfer tax return and the RP-5217 real property transfer report, which goes to the state’s assessment office. The two clerks currently list:
| Fee | Yates County Clerk (Penn Yan) | Steuben County Clerk (Bath) |
|---|---|---|
| Deed recording | $40 plus $5 per page (cover page required) | $45 including cover page, plus $5 per page |
| Mortgage recording | $40 plus $5 per page | $45 including cover page, plus $5 per page |
| TP-584 filing | $5 | $5 |
| RP-5217 filing | $125 residential/agricultural, $250 other | $125 residential/farm, $250 other |
| Residential deed notice fee | $10 | $10 |
Sources: Yates County fee schedule, Steuben County schedule of fees and Steuben land recording guide. A satisfaction of the seller’s old mortgage is also recorded, normally at the seller’s cost. In total, recording fees are small next to the taxes, but they show up on both sides of the closing statement.
Title: abstracts, searches and title insurance
Title work is where Keuka Lake closings differ most from what buyers from downstate or other states expect. The New York State Bar Association’s closing customs survey for Yates, Steuben and Schuyler counties describes local practice this way:
- The title search is an abstract of title covering at least 40 years, typically prepared by an abstract company and typically paid for by the seller, though a buyer can agree to pay some or all of it.
- A survey, when the buyer, the buyer’s attorney or the lender requires one, is typically a seller cost, again subject to negotiation.
- The deed is usually a warranty deed, and the buyer’s attorney usually records the closing documents.
- An owner’s title insurance policy is not customary locally. If the buyer wants one, the buyer pays for it.
- Septic inspections are required in most locations.
That survey was posted in 2020, and customs are only customs, so your purchase contract controls. If you are borrowing, expect the lender to require a lender’s (loan) title policy. The NYS Department of Financial Services’ title insurance guide explains that title insurance rates in New York are approved by DFS, most insurers use the rate manual filed by the Title Insurance Rate Service Association (TIRSA), and when an owner’s policy and a loan policy are issued at the same closing, the loan policy is charged 30% of its normal rate. Because rates are regulated, the premium itself doesn’t vary much between companies, but endorsements and other charges can.
Should a Keuka buyer get an owner’s policy?
It is optional, and the decision is worth a conversation with your attorney rather than a reflex. An owner’s policy protects you up to the purchase price if a covered title defect turns up later. Lake properties tend to have more of the things that cause title questions: old rights-of-way to the water, shared docks, private roads, boundary lines along the shore, and parcels that were split and recombined over generations. Our guides to lakefront vs. lake access, private roads and surveys and boundaries cover what to look for.
Lender and loan costs
If you finance, most of the variable costs come from the loan: origination charges, any points, the appraisal, credit report and flood certification fees, and prepaid items. The federal rules give you two documents to work with. Your lender’s Loan Estimate lists these costs early, and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains that lenders must provide the Closing Disclosure three business days before closing. Compare the two line by line, especially the loan amount, rate, closing costs and cash to close, and ask why anything changed.
Two lake-specific items deserve attention on the Loan Estimate. If the house is in a mapped flood zone and the loan is federally backed or regulated, the lender will require flood insurance, and the first year’s premium is usually paid at or before closing. And lenders on houses served by private roads often ask for a recorded road maintenance agreement, which can take weeks to produce if one doesn’t exist.
Prepaids, escrow and property tax adjustments
The CFPB describes prepaids as interest from the closing date to the end of the month plus, commonly, the first year’s homeowners insurance premium. If your loan has an escrow account, the lender also collects an initial deposit so it can pay your property taxes and insurance when they come due.
Property taxes are also adjusted between buyer and seller. In New York’s lake towns you’ll see separate town and county tax bills and school tax bills on different schedules, so at closing the seller is credited for any taxes paid in advance for time you’ll own the house, or you are credited for taxes the seller owes but hasn’t paid. Our Keuka Lake property tax guide lists the due dates, and the STAR credit guide for new homeowners explains why you should register for STAR soon after you close rather than assume the seller’s exemption carries over.
Inspections and lake-specific checks before closing
These aren’t closing costs on the statement, but they are money you’ll spend between contract and closing, and on a lake house they matter more than usual:
- A general home inspection, plus any add-ons it doesn’t cover, such as radon, well water testing, wood stove or chimney inspections, or a sewer or septic camera. See our home inspection guide.
- The septic inspection required at property transfer in the Keuka watershed. Our property transfer septic inspection guide explains who arranges it and what happens if the system fails.
- A survey, if the contract or lender requires one, especially where shoreline, dock or right-of-way questions exist.
- A records check with the town or village code office for open permits or missing certificates of occupancy. Our building permits guide covers what to ask.
- Insurance quotes, including flood, before you’re committed. See home insurance and flood insurance and lake levels.
One change helps buyers: since March 20, 2024, New York sellers can no longer give a $500 credit at closing instead of completing the Property Condition Disclosure Statement. As the New York State Association of REALTORS explains, sellers must deliver the amended disclosure form, which includes flood-history and flood-insurance questions, before the buyer signs a binding contract. Read it before you sign, and hand it to your inspector.
What the seller usually pays
Sellers sometimes ask what they’ll net, and buyers benefit from knowing what’s on the other side of the statement because it shapes negotiations. Typical seller costs around the lake include:
- The state transfer tax ($4 per $1,000 of the price) unless the contract shifts it.
- The abstract update and searches, and a survey if one is required, per the local customs above.
- Payoff of the existing mortgage and recording its satisfaction.
- Real estate commission, if an agent is involved, under the listing agreement.
- Their own attorney’s fee.
- Property tax credits owed to the buyer for unpaid periods.
- For a seller who doesn’t live in New York, estimated income tax on the gain, paid with Form IT-2663 when the deed is recorded, unless an exemption applies.
A worked buyer example (taxes and county fees only)
To give a sense of scale, here is the government-set portion for a buyer paying $400,000 with a $300,000 mortgage on a one-family house. It leaves out everything set by private parties (attorney, lender, title insurance, inspections, escrow and prepaids), which usually add up to more than the taxes.
| Item | Yates County | Steuben County |
|---|---|---|
| Mortgage recording tax (full rate, before any lender-paid share) | About $3,000 | About $3,725 |
| Mortgage recording (assume 20 pages) | $140 | $145 |
| Deed recording (assume 5 pages), TP-584, RP-5217 and deed notice fee | $205 | $210 |
| Mansion tax | None (under $1 million) | None (under $1 million) |
Page counts are assumptions for illustration; your attorney’s figures will differ. Who pays the deed recording fees and the RP-5217 is often settled in the contract, so ask.
How to keep closing costs under control
- Get Loan Estimates from more than one lender on the same day and compare origination charges and points side by side.
- Ask your attorney early for a written fee quote and an estimate of the full closing statement.
- Negotiate who pays for the survey, abstract update and recording fees in the purchase contract, not at the closing table.
- Order inspections promptly so problems can be priced into the deal before deadlines pass.
- If you’re buying near or above $1 million, have the mansion tax in your budget from the start.
- Never wire money based on emailed instructions alone. Call your attorney at a number you already know to confirm wiring details before sending funds.
Get quotes from local pros
Tell us what you need and we’ll pass your request to up to 3 local businesses who can quote it. Free, no obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Who pays the transfer tax when buying a house at Keuka Lake?
Usually the seller. New York’s Tax Department says the base transfer tax ($2 per $500 of price) is the seller’s responsibility unless the contract says otherwise, but the buyer becomes liable if the seller doesn’t pay. The 1% mansion tax on homes of $1 million or more is paid by the buyer.
How much is the mortgage tax in Yates and Steuben counties?
Per the state’s MT-15 rate tables, Yates County totals $1.00 per $100 of mortgage debt and Steuben County $1.25 per $100, because Steuben also imposes the additional tax. On many residential loans the lender pays the 25-cent special additional portion.
Do I need an owner’s title insurance policy?
It isn’t required, and a 2020 NYSBA survey of Yates, Steuben and Schuyler county customs says it isn’t customary locally; a buyer who wants one pays for it. Lenders generally require a loan policy. Ask your attorney whether the property’s history makes an owner’s policy worth it.
Who pays for the abstract and survey?
By local custom, typically the seller, according to the same NYSBA survey, though the contract can change that. A survey is usually done only when the buyer, the buyer’s attorney or the lender requires one.
Can the seller give me $500 instead of the property disclosure form?
Not anymore. Since March 20, 2024, New York requires sellers to deliver the Property Condition Disclosure Statement before the buyer signs a binding contract; the old $500 credit option was eliminated.
When will I see my final closing costs?
Your lender must give you the Closing Disclosure three business days before closing. Your attorney prepares the closing statement with the tax adjustments and other items. Compare both with your Loan Estimate and ask about any differences.
Official sources
- NYS Tax Department: Real estate transfer tax
- NYS Tax Department: Mortgage recording tax
- NYS Tax Form MT-15 (rate tables by county)
- Yates County Clerk: Fee schedule
- Steuben County Clerk: Schedule of fees
- Steuben County Clerk: Land recording guide
- NYSBA: Residential closing customs, Yates, Steuben and Schuyler counties (PDF)
- NYS Department of Financial Services: Title insurance
- CFPB: Closing Disclosure explainer
- NYSAR: Amended PCDS eliminating the $500 credit
Related on Living on Keuka: Buying a home near Keuka Lake · Keuka Lake real estate market · Lakefront vs. lake access · Home inspections · Septic inspection at transfer · Property taxes · STAR for new homeowners · Building permits
Across the network: Living on Seneca: buying a home on Seneca Lake checklist · Hornell Living: buying an older home checklist
Spot something out of date? Tell us.
